Category Archives: Temperature

Malaysian Flight 370: Lithium Battery Fire Is A Reasonable Hypothesis

777The cargo fire hypothesized by Canadian pilot Chris Goodfellow to explain the disappearance of Malaysian Flight 370 (see “Malaysian Flight 370: Canadian pilot’s analysis goes viral“) is a reasonable one.

According to Malaysian officials, the plane was carrying 440 pounds of lithium batteries. Lithium batteries, sitting inert (not being charged or discharged), were identified as the cause of the fire and resultant 2010 crash of a UPS 747 flight at Dubai. Ironically, even though “improper storage” in that case was determined to be the cause of the fire, I have never read any explanation of how improper storage can ignite a lithium battery. It appears more likely that lithium batteries, under certain conditions not completely understood (e.g. a combination of battery construction and chemistry, heat, vibration, and/or shock) can spontaneously ignite, albeit very rarely.

In addition to pilot Goodfellow’s comments, an added interesting point is that Flight 370 also gained very high altitude shortly after communications ceased. It could be that the pilots, upon becoming aware of the fire at that time, tried to quickly elevate the plane to quell the fire by starving it of oxygen. This might have been an excellent maneuver for most fires, but lithium batteries, once ignited, create their own oxygen and will continue to burn at high altitude.

Bottom Line: Until the cause of the disappearance of Flight 370 is positively determined, the possibility of a lithium battery fire is a reasonable hypothesis, and worth investigating.

-Ed Walker

 

Advertisements

4th Quarter 2009

(C) 2009 Design/Analysis Consultants, Inc.
Newsletter content may be copied in whole or part if attribution
to DACI and any referenced sources is prominently displayed with the copied material

This Issue: News Bite: Giant Spider Attacks Liverpool / News Bullet ALERT: Exploding iPods and iPhones / Tech Tip: Preventing Capacitor Meltdown / Sightings: When Managers Pretend to be Engineers

NEWS BITE: Giant Spider Attacks Liverpool!

arachnoid(“Arachnoid Affair,” IEEE Spectrum, Nov 2008)

image007 NEWS BULLETS ALERT!

What, Me Worry? According to Apple Computer, Inc., a rash of exploding iPods and iPhones are “isolated incidents.” (Breitbart.com, 18 Aug 2009)

Our View: The claim of “isolated incidents” is believed to be highly improbable. First, the term “isolated incidents” is an oxymoron; how can a scattered group of incidents be considered isolated? Second, over a period spanning hundreds of projects and problem investigations, we have never seen a case that resulted in a root cause of “isolated incidents”; there has always been a specific cause, usually related to insufficient design margin. In this particular case, an industry history of battery explosions suggests a likely hypothesis: the batteries used by Apple are fabricated in a manner that is not compatible with their charge/discharge stresses.

Until this is cleared up, it would be wise to contact Apple and insist that they guarantee that your particular iPods and iPhones will not explode or catch fire, or provide a refund.

fire TECH TIP: Preventing Capacitor Meltdown

Stress Analysis: Capacitors

CORE TEMPERATURE

Operating within a capacitor’s core temperature rating is generally assured by confirming that the capacitor’s rms ripple current rating is not exceeded. (Vendors often specify ripple current ratings because ripple currents are a good predictor of core temperature and can be directly measured, whereas it usually isn’t possible to measure the core temperature.) For some applications involving very high ripple currents, capacitor mounting and heat sinking may be critical. In those cases it may be necessary to perform a complete thermal analysis to compute the core temperature:

Tcore = Ths + Rchs * Irms^2 * ESR

where

Tcore = capacitor core temperature, C

Ths = heat sink temperature, C

Rchs = thermal resistance from core to heat sink, C/W (as provided by the capacitor vendor)

Irms = capacitor ripple current, amps RMS

ESR = capacitor equivalent series resistance at ripple frequency, ohms

BugAlert Whenever possible, be sure to mount capacitors away from local heat sources, such as power devices and their heat sinks.

bozo SIGHTINGS: When Managers Pretend to be Engineers
Sightings is a collection of true experiences as reported by credible sources

Charlie the consultant was on the phone. His client, for what must have been the tenth time, was once again directing Charlie to implement yet another trivial product change.

As the client droned on, Charlie leaned back, stretched his legs, and then silently chuckled as an old adage popped into his head. The Peter Principle, from a book of the same name by Dr. Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull, said that “…every employee tends to rise to his level of incompetence.” That observation particularly applies to engineering administrators, thought Charlie, ones like his client, Mr. O, who lacked the benefit of an engineering education or any related experience. It all seemed so trivial to Mr. O, whose latest hot flash was that a front panel LED should be changed from green to yellow.

Charlie knew from experience that there were literally dozens of key issues to be addressed in his client’s product design, and the color of LEDs was not among them. There were critical performance concerns such as efficiency and thermal management, as well as immutable compliance mandates, including safety and EMI. In fact, compliance requirements dictated the color of the LED, so changing the color was not really an option.

Mr. O’s shrill tone snapped Charlie out of his reverie. “Well then, Charlie, what about it?”

“Um, I’m sorry Mr. O, but we can’t change the color due to safety regulations.”

“Well then,” barked Mr. O, “if you can’t change the color, then make it blink. That should be easy.”

“Well,” replied Charlie, “making it blink would not be difficult, but that would still violate the safety requirement. For its function the LED has to be on continuously; it can’t blink.”

“Can you change the name of the function?”

Charlie paused, momentarily nonplussed, and then said, “Uh, no, sorry. That would still be a violation.” Charlie sighed and waited silently for Mr. O to process the fact that the LED should not be changed.

“I’ve got it! I’ve got it!” shouted Mr. O, forcing Charlie to pull the phone away from his ear. “Just add another LED, one that’s not related to a safety function!”

“Um — well — um,” stammered Charlie, “Um, we don’t really need another function…”

“And make it pink!”

Charlie felt his gut tighten, girding himself to once again patiently overcome Mr. O’s stubbornness. But suddenly Charlie relaxed, remembering that Mr. O was paying for all of this nonsense.

“Sure,” said Charlie. “We’ll put in a function that can use a pink LED.” After a pause, he smiled and then added, “Would you like it to blink?”